Navigating the Future: Succession Planning, Mergers, and Managing Evolution
- Only about 35% of advisors have a well-structured, written succession plan, up from 25% two decades ago.
- Succession stalls for psychological reasons, such as letting go of control, and structural ones: internal, external, and governance decisions.
- Begin with a clear foundation: a five-year vision for your role and an ideal succession timeline.
- More than a third of founders believe their G2 cannot afford a buyout. Test affordability with valuation, projections, tranches, and compensation math.
- External sales may yield valuations two or more times higher than internal sales, which often carry discounts of 25% or more.
- Founder confidence depends on intentional development: defined career paths, a documented path to ownership, and early transfer of management responsibilities.
Why do most RIA succession plans stall?
– Insights from David DeVoe at the 2026 ClientWise Ensemble Leaders’ Summit –
For most firm founders and senior leaders, building an advisory firm is a lifelong labor of love. You nurture an organization from the ground up, turning it into a thriving engine of client service and value. Yet, as the business matures, you inevitably face some of the most critical business decisions of your career: navigating the complex landscape of mergers and acquisitions, and ultimately executing a successful business transition strategy.
David DeVoe, Founder and CEO of DeVoe & Company, explored these challenges at our recent ClientWise Ensemble Leaders’ Summit (ELS) 2026. Drawing on over two decades of specialized consulting and M&A experience, he reflected on the current state of the RIA industry and highlighted a glaring paradox. While many advisory firms seem to excel at organic growth – often expanding at an impressive clip of around 18% annually – most continue to struggle mightily with succession challenges.
The Planning Crisis: Why So Many Successions Fail
When DeVoe began tracking RIA M&A and succession activity more than twenty years ago, a dismal 25% of advisors had a well-structured, written succession plan in place. Despite decades of urging on the part of industry leaders, platform experts, and consultants, that figure has only gradually inched up its present 35%.
Why do so many founders procrastinate when it comes to such a critical business imperative?
The barrier is largely psychological. As humans, we’re naturally hardwired to resist change, especially when it involves letting go of control, confronting aging, and contemplating retirement. It’s a slippery slope that touches on deeply personal fears.
Beyond psychology, however, there’s also structural complexity. Succession planning begins as a seemingly simple concept: deciding whether to pursue an internal sale, an external sale, or some hybrid of the two. Often, however, it quickly becomes mired in uncertainty due to:
- Internal Complexities: Do you have one or more qualified successors in-house? Are they adequately prepared and can they afford it? How do you migrate not just equity and ownership, but also management responsibilities?
- External Complexities: Should you sell to a third party, merge with a complementary firm, or acquire a smaller practice (a ‘mini-me’) to serve as your successor?
- Governance and Risk: What happens if a shareholder leaves unexpectedly? Many firms lack a proper methodology to buy back shares, creating massive exposure points. Do founders really want to act as the bank, financing the buyout themselves? Furthermore, how do you handle shareholder agreements, key-man insurance, and professional development in marketing, accounting, and finance?
Faced with this avalanche of decisions, even the savviest of founders may find themselves starting, stopping, and stalling the succession planning process for years.
To break this paralysis, leaders need to take a step back and focus on beginning with a clear foundation: explicitly defining their succession goals and objectives. Before jumping into deal structures or valuations, founders should:
- Outline your five-year business vision alongside your personal and professional roles. Perhaps you would prefer to focus more on business development and relationship management, while dialing back on day-to-day investment management and oversight.
- Define your ideal succession timeline. Does it look like one day flicking the switch from ‘on’ to ‘off,’ or a more gradual stepping back 20% each year?
Establishing this personal North Star can help transform what might otherwise be an overwhelming task into a clearer and more manageable checklist.
How to Test the Affordability of an Internal Succession Plan
If you’re leaning towards an internal succession, a stark reality check is required. Namely, can your designated next generation successor(s) actually afford to buy you out?
DeVoe & Company’s annual tracking data casts serious doubt. While figures somewhat fluctuate year-to-year as a result of broader economic headwinds, more than a third of all founders are consistently expressing a strong conviction that their G2 teams will not be able to afford a buyout under current conditions.
If you’re uncertain whether your internal successors have the financial capacity, it’s not that difficult to run a simple back-of-the-envelope assessment based on the following analysis:
- Establish a Valuation: Start with a rigorous valuation. While an advanced discounted cash flow (DCF) model offers ultimate accuracy, a baseline cash flow multiple can provide a quick starting point.
- Project Future Value: Map out projected firm valuations over the upcoming years.
- Plan Tranches: Determine when equity will be migrated and in what percentages (e.g., selling 20% in year one, another tranche in year two).
- Run the Math: Compare the cost of each tranche against projected next generation compensation, bonuses, and borrowing capacity.
If the math falls short in later years, consider options for getting creative with loan structures, down payments, and/or valuation discounts. However, if an internal succession proves mathematically impossible, it’s better to recognize that reality sooner rather than later so you can pivot gracefully towards external alternatives – before it becomes an emergency.
What Drives the Internal vs. External Succession Valuation Gap
Keep in mind that selling externally to a private equity-backed buyer or sophisticated consolidator may offer the potential to yield a valuation that’s two or more times higher than an internal sale. It’s an historically wide delta in the current marketplace – one which founders should carefully consider.
Internal buyouts often involve discounts (typically 25% or more) as a concession to successors. And private equity-backed buyers bring sophisticated, methodical management teams that look closely at whether your firm actually fits as an integral piece to their strategic puzzle.
When there’s an emphatic ‘yes,’ these buyers are then willing to pay a substantial premium – widening the gap even further between the lowest and highest valuations in the marketplace.
Management Migration and Developing the Next Generation
Affordability is only half the battle. The other critical hurdle is confidence. Increasingly, G1 founders are expressing growing concern over whether G2 and G3 are truly prepared to effectively run and sustain the enterprise.
When founders lack confidence in next generation leadership capabilities, transitions stall. The solution lies in ‘intentional development.’ Surveys of next generation professionals consistently highlight the following top two requests:
- A clearer and more well-defined career path (cited by roughly 45% of respondents); and
- A documented path to ownership and partnership.
The firms that most successfully unlock long-term value are those that formalize career paths, provide structured coaching, and begin transitioning operational management responsibilities long before the founder steps away.
Navigating Firm Life Cycles: The Professional Management Chasm
An RIA firm’s journey from inception to thriving enterprise typically moves through four very distinct life stages:
- The Advisory Practice: A founder-led practice under $100M that encompasses one or two advisors along with a few admin and/or operational support professionals.
- The RIA Business: A sustainable growing concern that’s comprised of multiple advisors, where the business has the ability to survive an unexpected disruption.
- The Professionally Managed Firm: A critical inflection point where someone (either a partner or a hired COO/President) devotes 100% of their time to running the business rather than managing client relationships.
- The Enterprise: A large-scale, multi-disciplinary organization (often $5B+) with dedicated professional management teams across technology, compliance, and finance.
The transition from an RIA business to a professionally managed firm is arguably the most challenging chasm to cross. Founders are notoriously independent (and reluctant to relinquish control) which makes it exceedingly difficult to hand over the reins of operations and decision-making.
Growth and profitability often dip temporarily during this transition, as the firm absorbs executive overhead. Yet, pulling back that slingshot allows the firm to snap forward into a much stronger, self-sustaining organization.
Alternatively, smaller firms frequently choose to bypass this painful chasm altogether by merging into larger, professionally-managed enterprises that have already built out the necessary infrastructure.
Whether you’re a founder charting an internal succession roadmap, a next generation leader stepping into ownership, or an acquirer looking to rescue an unstructured practice, clarity will always be your greatest asset. By defining your personal and professional goals early, addressing affordability and management readiness head-on, and approaching business evolution with clear-eyed realism, you have an opportunity to safeguard your life’s work and position your business for enduring success.
Coaching Questions From This Article
- When you picture your professional role five years from now, what do you envision changing? What would your ideal transition look like, and what’s preventing you from defining that timeline today?
- If you’re leaning towards an internal succession, does the math make a G2 buyout feasible/affordable? Are you fully-aligned on the financial trade-offs you’ll need to make compared to an external sale?
- What specific responsibilities and decisions can you begin actively transferring to next generation leaders today, to help build confidence in their ability to run the enterprise without you?
- As your firm scales, are you prepared to delegate non-client management to dedicated operational leaders? Or would merging into a larger enterprise infrastructure serve as a better path for your vision?
Ray Sclafani
Founder & CEO, ClientWise
Ray Sclafani is the Founder & CEO of ClientWise, a premier business and executive coaching firm serving financial advisors, advisory teams, and wealth management leaders nationwide. A recognized authority on advisory firm growth, leadership, succession, and enterprise development, Ray has coached many of the industry's top-performing advisory firms and teams.
Ray is the host of the Building the Billion Dollar Business podcast, co-host of Contrasting Viewpoints published by Financial Advisor magazine, and a featured guest host of Barron's Advisor's The Way Forward podcast. He is also the author of You've Been Framed, a book focused on helping financial advisors clarify their value, strengthen client relationships, and transition from transactional advisor to trusted advocate.
Through his coaching, speaking, writing, and podcasting, Ray helps advisory firms scale sustainably through stronger leadership, organizational alignment, team development, and long-term enterprise thinking.
See the award →
View finalists →
View finalists →
Why do so many advisory firm succession plans fail?
How do I know if my next generation successors can afford to buy me out?
Is an internal or external sale worth more for an RIA?
What do next generation advisors want from their firms?
What is the professional management chasm in an RIA?
